25. Company, Sullivan Rep
Ambitious and amusingly retro, Dan Sullivan’s production was both achingly tender and deliriously funny.
24. Fun Home, The Huntington
At The Huntington, Fun Home drew much of its emotional force from Jennifer Ellis as Helen, whose restrained, slow-breaking portrait of a woman holding a family together became the production’s cornerstone.
23. Misery, Merrimack Repertory Theatre
Flaws of the stage adaptation aside, Courtney Sale’s production was nonetheless tense and terrifying, anchored by Karen MacDonald’s stellar turn as one of Stephen King’s most enduring villains.
22. The Meeting Tree, Company One Theatre
Tender and piercing, Elle Borders’ world premiere play was a sweeping drama that landed with real emotional weight, shaped by Summer L. Williams’ graceful direction.
21. A Man of No Importance, SpeakEasy Stage
A fitting swan song for longtime artistic director Paul Daigneault, A Man of No Importance was beautifully performed and artfully realized.
20. 300 Paintings, American Repertory Theater
With 300 Paintings, Sam Kissajukian transformed a whirlwind burst of creative obsession into a riveting solo performance that was funny, raw, and unexpectedly profound.
19. Our Class, Arlekin Players
At Arlekin Players, Our Class emerged as a stark, unflinching ensemble drama whose moral reckoning accumulated into one of the year’s most haunting theatrical experiences. Igor Golyak, I would follow you anywhere.
18. The Beautiful Land I Seek, Teatro Chelsea
At Teatro Chelsea, The Beautiful Land I Seek wove history, migration, and memory into a moving mosaic, carried by an ensemble whose sincerity and vitality made the story feel real and resonant.
17. Rent, North Shore Music Theatre
The finest production of Rent I’ve ever seen beyond the original Michael Greif staging, North Shore Music Theatre’s revival crackled with purpose and urgency, its passionate ensemble and expansive, carefully shaped staging charged the show with a spirit that felt both nostalgic and refreshingly new.
16. tick, tick…BOOM!, The Umbrella Stage Company
At The Umbrella Arts Center, tick, tick…BOOM! became a moving tribute to artistic persistence, shaped with delicacy and purpose by Ilyse Robbins and powered by a trio of performances that made Jonathan Larson’s anxieties and hopes feel piercingly alive.
15. Mother Mary, Boston Playwrights’ Theatre
The finest new script of the year, KJ Moran Velz’s Mother Mary was a tender, boldly imagined love story of faith, queerness, and self-determination, realized through luminous performances and clear, compassionate direction against the backdrop of a bygone Boston.
14. The Garbologists, Gloucester Stage Company
At Gloucester Stage, The Garbologists turned an unlikely partnership into one of the year’s most affecting two-handers, driven by nuanced performances and direction that found real humor and heartbreak in the everyday.
13. Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York), American Repertory Theater

This musical rom-com’s scrappy, big-hearted charm crystallized around Sam Tutty’s lovable, show-stealing lead performance, one that ought to earn him a Tony nomination next year.
12. Our Town, Lyric Stage Boston
In Courtney O’Connor’s revival, Our Town unfolded with a spare, deliberate restraint that allowed its everyday moments to swell into something luminous and quietly devastating.
11. Jaja’s African Hair Braiding, SpeakEasy Stage'
In Summer L. Williams’ perfect production, Jaja’s African Hair Braiding began as a lively, funny slice-of-life portrait and gradually revealed a far more precarious reality beneath the salon’s bustle and humor. I’ve hardly stopped thinking about it since.
10. The Piano Lesson, Actors’ Shakespeare Project
At Actors’ Shakespeare Project, The Piano Lesson marked another high point in the company’s ongoing engagement with August Wilson’s work. Under Christopher V. Edwards’ direction, Omar Robinson brought a forceful, clear-eyed drive to Boy Willie, a performance that finally earned him a long-overdue Elliot Norton Award. Opposite him, Anthony T. Goss offered a warmth and unforced comic lift that proved just as memorable, earning him his second Norton in as many years. This spring, ASP returns to Hibernian Hall with Gem of the Ocean, the company’s fourth entry in Wilson’s indispensable Century Cycle.
9. Topdog/Underdog, Lanes Coven Theater Co.
At Lane’s Coven in Rockport, Suzan-Lori Parks’ Topdog/Underdog became something startlingly new and deeply revealing. Kadeem Ali Harris’s taut, sharply observed production exposed the hunger, envy, and tenderness beneath this Pulitzer-winning play. At its center, Adrianna Mitchell and Akilah A. Walker gave astounding performances that shifted between swagger and fragility with breathtaking skill. The result made an oft-produced modern classic feel newly dangerous and alive.
8. The Mountaintop, Front Porch Arts Collective
Maurice Emmanuel Parent’s revival was one of the most affecting productions I saw all year — measured at first, then overwhelming in its emotional force. Anchored by two astonishing performances from Dominic Carter and Kiera Prusmack, Katori Hall’s The Mountaintop was raw and genuinely revelatory.
7. Kimberly Akimbo, Broadway In Boston
On tour, the Tony Award-winning Kimberly Akimbo proved to be one of the most life-affirming shows of the year — a musical about illness, dysfunction, and small-time crime that works far better than it has any right to. As Kimberly, the sharp-witted teenage girl living with a rare condition that causes her to age rapidly, Carolee Carmello was the anchor, playing the role with a mix of wit, candor, and emotional precision that held the show’s oddball world firmly in place.
6. The Hills of California, The Huntington
Jez Butterworth’s portrait of four sisters circling old wounds, buried ambitions and the gravity of a dying mother built its power gradually, rewarding patient attention with a third-act gut punch I won’t soon forget.
5. Parade, Emerson Colonial Theatre
The national tour of Michael Arden’s Tony-winning revival of Parade made the Leo Frank case feel brutally close at hand, tracing how hatred, hysteria, and good old Southern nativism curdled into an unforgivable injustice. Arden’s staging framed the story as both intimate tragedy and public spectacle, turning this modern classic into one of the year’s most bracing nights at the theater.
4. The Glass Menagerie, Gloucester Stage Company
At Gloucester Stage, Doug Lockwood’s production of The Glass Menagerie emerged with a depth and fidelity to Tennessee Williams that felt both grounded and newly revealing. The production’s most resonant insight came from casting Tom as the only Black member of a white family, living under the watchful portrait of the Black father who abandoned them — a choice that no doubt sharpened his sense of isolation and lent new weight to the resentment, sorrow, and drinking that pull him even farther from the life he’s trapped inside. Paired with superb performances and breathtaking design, this was a Menagerie that didn’t try to reinvent the play; it simply allowed it to ache in new ways.
3. The Light in the Piazza, The Huntington
Ravishing in every sense, Loretta Greco’s The Light in the Piazza felt like a postcard brought to life. Set against sun-struck Florence and steeped in fragile, unexpected romance, the production bloomed with warmth and emotional precision, illuminating both the swoon of first love and the complicated bond between mother and daughter. I left the theater in a complete daze.
2. Hamilton, Broadway In Boston
Few shows in recent memory have felt as pointedly relevant as Hamilton did this year. Its portrait of ambition, power, and fragile nation-building carried an added charge in a political moment when the threads of democracy feel perilously thin. I’ve seen Hamilton six times now, and each time it takes my breath away.
1. The Grove, The Huntington
In 2025, nothing matched the emotional resonance or spiritual depth of Awoye Timpo’s staging of The Grove, Mfoniso Udofia’s richly textured portrait of the Ufot family at a moment of reckoning. Its power lay in the way it gathered so many currents at once — grief, inheritance, queerness, migration, faith, and the uneasy pull of generational memory and ancestry — all shaped with a profound dramatic intelligence.


























